Analogue to digital conversion apparatus



ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 1 SIGNAL wmcn MAY VARY THROUGH A RANGE HAVING A mom MIDVALUE QUANTIZER STAGE 89%; 525W ZETWEEN AN IN UT D A STANDARD 2| QUANTIZER 1 STAGE SOURCE OF STANDARD VOLT- AGES RELATED TO ONE HALF 27 THE MAXIMUM SIGNAL BY s ccEsgga gfl- 25 35 BINARY QUANTIZER OF TWO STAGE DEEIMAL CONVERTER INDICATOR QUANTIZER STAGE INVENTOR FLOYD D. RAASCH ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 2 l/B STD.

INVENTOR Cw FLOYD 0. RAASOH I '4 ATTORNEY 3, 1 0 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,469

ANALOGUE T0 DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 3 N ikg asg w a? I I (n I 3 P D 1 f r r m RQS J J 3 h D 1 J 1 Q 5 'bEO-h an KIT 4 .9 M S INVENTOR c FLOYD o. RAASCH i S BY ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS 16 Sheets-Sheet 4 Filed April 14, 1954 Q5 .52: Z36 Qmxru I N VEN TOR FLOYD D. RAASCH ATTORNEY 8- 1960 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,469

ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 5 FIXED GAIN AMP a DISCR INVENTOR FLOYD D.. RAASCH ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. DJRAASCH 2,950,469

1 v ANALOGUE To DIGITAL. CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14', 1954 1 1e Sheets-Shet 6 I INVENTOR FLOYD 0. RAASCH ATTORNEY 1950 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,469

ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet '7 V2 STD.

INVENTOR FLOYD 0. RAASCH BY WJ ATTORNEY SIGNAL Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 8 FLOYD D. RAASCH BY fax;

ATTORNEY Aug. 3. 1 0 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,469

ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 9 INVENTOR FLOYD D. RAASCH ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,469

ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 10 INVENTOR ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,459

ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheec,s--S!'1eet ll INVENTOR vq FLOYD o. E EY 7 ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAAscH ANALOGUE T0 DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14. 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 12 ATTORNEY Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet 15 o QT Q. Q. QT Qm Qm QT g QQ. Q T QT QT o o QT Q. Q. QT Qm Qm QM T o QT Q. QT QT Q. Q. QT Q Qm Qm T Q. QT Q. QT QT o o QT Q. Q. Q. T c Q. Q. QT QT Q. QT QT Qm Qm Q T QT QT c o QT Q. QT QT Q. Q. Q. T o QT Q. Q. QT Q Q? QT Q. Q. Q. T Q. QT Q. Q. QT Q. QT QT o o T 0 Q. T Q. Q. QT Qm Q- QT Q. QT g T QT QT o o QT Q. QT QT Q. QT Q T o QT Q. QT QT Q. QT QT Qm Qn Qn T Q. QT QT QT o o QT Q. QT Q. T o QT Q. QT QT Q. Q. QT Qm Qm Q T QT Q. o o QT Q. Q. QT Qm Qm- Q. T o QT Q. Q. QT Qm Qm QT Q- Q? Q. T Q. Q. Q. Q. QT Q. Q. QT T o T 8 59 N5 5 So. .5 8 So. 05 So. won muwwww 13 0w mmwmm muflwmw nmwm wmfimm. mwwm kmmw wwmmm z m 9. $2.3 32.2 82.3 $9.3

m. QE

Aug. 23, 1960 F. D. RAASCH 2,950,459

ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Filed April 14, 1954 16 Sheets-Sheet l6 souRcE 0F STANDARD VOLT- AGEs RELATED To oNE HALF THE /2l MAXIMUM SIGNAL BY SUCCESSIVE NEGATIVE POWERS OF TWO QUANTIZER sTAGE GIvING AN OUTPUT WHICH Is A N0N- 33 LIN-:AR FUNCTION 0F TI-E RELATION BETWEEN AN INPUT AND A STANDARD QUANTIZER sTAGE SIGNAL WHICH MAY VARY 2? THROUGH A RANGE HAVING A KNOWN 25 DEC'MAL MIDVALUE 35 DEGIMAL CONVERTER INoIcATo ouANTIzER sTAGE 4i I l l l 32 I l l QUANTIZER sTAGE .F/E. 1A

INVENTOR. FLOYD o. RAASCH ATTORNEY United States Patent ANALOGUE TO DIGITAL CONVERSION APPARATUS Floyd Daniel Raasch, St. Louis Park, Minn., assignor to Minneapolis-Honeywell Regulator Company, Minneapolis, Minn., a corporation of Delaware Filed Apr. 14, 1954, Ser. No. 423,049

4 Claims. (Cl. 340347) This invention relates to the field of computers, and particularly to computing devices for giving a digital output when energized with an analogue input: such devices are referred to generally as quantizers.

There are two basic types of automatic computers which are generally recognized. One of these is the analogue type, in which parameters are in theory continuously variable: the other is the digital type in which parameters may have only discrete values. Each type of computer has advantages and disadvantages: one of the disadvantages of digital computers is the relative complexity of sensing elements. Analogue-output sensing devices are simple, reliable and inexpensive, and accordingly the present invention relates to means for converting analogue signals to a form usable in digital computation.

Every computer whether analogue or digital is based on a number system. In analogue computers it is convenient to use the ordinary decimal system, in which any number is a polynomial made up of the sum of a plurality of terms each of which is the product of a coefficient multiplied by a power of ten, ten being the radix of the decimal system. The Arabic numerals from Zero to nine are the coeflicients use, in their usual order of increasing magnitude. Thus 374 is an abbreviated way of expressing the polynomial 3 +7 10 +4 10.

The binary system of numbers is more convenient to use in high speed electronic computers since here only two coefiicients are needed, namely zero and one, and these may be represented by the open and closed positions respectively of a simple switch. In the binary system the radix is two instead of ten. Thus the binary number 110010 is an abbreviated way of expressing the polynomial 1 2 +1 2 +0 2 +0 2 +1 2 +0 2.

The processes of digital computation are essentially those of counting. In either the binary system or the decimal system there are times in the course of counting when more than one figure in a number changes at the same time. Thus, between 199 and 200 in the decimal system and between 011 and 100 in the binary system, each of three figures changes. When more than one figure should in theory be changed at any signal level, there is always the possibility that due to manufacturing tolerances the different figures may change at slightly dilferent signal levels. This could result in anomalous readings over a narrow range of signal voltage around the transition level, although over the whole range of the signals the readings should still be accurate. It has been found that by using the figures zero and one in a slightly difierent order than that customary in binary counting, it is possible to arrange a counting circuit so that there never need be change in more than one figure at a time: such an arrangement is called a progressive or reflected binary code. Counting in the simple binary system begins as follows: 0, 1, 10, 11, 100, 101, 110, 1,11, 1,000, etc.; in the progressive binary system it begins as follows: 0,1, 11, 10, 110, 111, 101, 100, 1,100, etc.

The procedure described above was previously recogprogressive decimal number 325.

ice

nized and is known as the Gray code, but has been limited to numbers in the binary system. I have discovered that the same principle can be extended to systems having any radix. Thus the consecutive decimal numbers from zero to thirty, if expressed in the progressive decimal system, would read 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 19, 18, 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, 10, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 39.

For larger numbers the conversion between simple and progressive decimal expressions may be explained as follows. The simple decimal number 374 is the same as the In converting from simple to progressive expressions copy the first figure of the simple decimal number without change. If the figure so copied is even, copy the second figure without change, but if the first-copied figure is odd, replace the second figure by its nines complement, that is, by 9 minus the figure. Now if the sum of the figures copied is even, copy the next figure in the simple decimal number without change: if the sum is odd, replace the next figure in the simple decimal number by its nines complement to get the next figure in the progressive decimal number. Repeat the operation described in the last sentence as often as is necessary to complete the number, each time summing all the available figures in the progressive decimal number.

In converting from progressive to simple decimal numbers, copy the first figure of the progressive decimal number. If this figure is even, copy the second figure of the progressive decimal number unchanged, but if the first figure is odd, replace the second figure by its nines complementt. If the sum of the first two figures in the progressive decimal number being converted is even, copy the third figure unchanged: if the sum is odd, replace the third figure by its nines complement. Repeat the operation described in the last sentence as often as necessary to complete the number, each time summing all the figures in the progressive decimal number which precede the figure under consideration to determine whether it or its nines complement is to be used.

For general numbers in a simple system having a radix R and written A R +A R +A R +A R +A R+A R the progressive system equivalent may be written M R +M R +M R +M R +M R+M R where M for any term is equal to A for that term, or to (R1)A, according as the sum of the preceding Ms is even or odd. Similarly, for general numbers in a progressive system having a radix R and written A R"+A R +A R +A R +A R+A R the simple system equivalent may be written n (n1) +M3R3+M2R2+M1R+M0RU where M for any term is equal to A for that term, or to (R1)A, according as the sum of the preceding As is even or odd.

From the foregoing it will be apparent that the number of objects represented by 374 in the simple decimal sys- "tem is' represented by the number 325 in the progressive decimal system, by the number 000101000101 in the simple binary system, and by the number 000111100111 in the progressive binary system. One other method of representation should also be described, in which the figures of a decimal number are individually expressed as their binary equivalents, which are then written together in the apparent form of a single binary number. According to this system the decimal number 325 would be expressed by the simple binary number 001100100101, the first four figures representing 3, the next four representing 2 and the last four figures representing 5. Similarly the same decimal number could be represented by the progressive binary number 001000110111, the first four, middle four, and last four numbers respectively representing 3, 2 and 5.

Automatic devices can be set up to use any of these forms of expressing numbers, or combinations of such forms. Moreover, some other starting figure than zero can be used in any counting system, since all counting consists .merely of manipulating symbols arbitrarily assigned to represent quantities of arbitrarily selected magnitude.

The broad object of the invention is to provide improved, means for converting analogue data to digital form.

Another object of the invention is to provide a digital quantizer in which non-linear elements are used to obtain the desired quantization.

Another object of the invention is to provide such a quantizer in which the non-linear elements are switching devices.

,Another object of the invention is to provide such a quantizer in which the non-linear elements are rectifiers.

Another object of the invention is to provide such a quantizer in which the non-linear elements include squaring and square root taking means.

Yet another object of the invention is to provide such a data converter in which an analogue signal voltage is compared with one or more standard voltages in one or more quantizer stages, the stage outputs giving the digital equivalent of the signal voltage.

A specific object of the invention is to provide such a data converter in which a plurality of quantizer stages are arranged to give digital outputs rep-resenting, in distinguishable binary outputs, the digits of a decimal numher.

A further object of the invention is to provide digital computing apparatus especially adapted for use with progressively coded decimal numbers.

Various other objects, advantages, and features of novelty which characterize my invention are pointed out with particularity in the claims annexed hereto and forming a part hereof. However, for a better understanding of the invention, its advantages, and objects attained by its use, reference should be had to the subjoined drawing,

which forms a further part heretof, and to the accompany-.

ing descriptive. matter, in which I have illustrated and described certain preferred embodiments of my invention. In the drawings:

Figures 1 and 1A are block diagrams illustrative of typical analogue-to-digital converters or digital quantizers having decimal outputs;

Figure 2 shows one specific quantizer relying on switching operation to give the non-linearity on which quantizer operation is based;

Figure 3 shows a modification of Figure 2 adapted to give separate binary outputs corresponding to decimal digits;

Figures 4, 5 and 6 show additional quantizers relying on switching operation to give the desired, non-1inearity;

Figure 7 shows a quantizer relying on squaring and square-rooting apparatus to give the desired non-linearity;

Figures 8-121 are diagrams illustrative of voltage relations in the structure of Figure 7;

Figures 12 and =13 are diagrammatic illustrations of quantizers in which rectifiers are relied upon to give the desired non-linearity; and

Figure 14 shows a readout circuit for giving decimal indications of an analogue input, converted to binary data by apparatus like that of Figure 4, modified as taught in connection with Figure 3;

Figure 15 is a diagram illustrative of the relation between computers based on progressive and simple number systems; and V Figures 16, 17, 18, and'19 are tables showing voltage relations in certain embodiments of the invention.

In Figure 1 the analogue signal voltage which is to be converted to a digital response is shown at 20, and a source of standard voltages is shown at 21. The standard voltages are shown as having the magnitude relation of successive negative powers of two, the first and largest being equal in magnitude to half the anticipated maximum value of signal 20. The first quantiz'er stage 22 is energized from sources 29 and 21, and gives an output at 23 which depends on the relation between the inputs to the stage. Further similar quantizer stages 24, 25, and 26 are shown as energized from source 21: a second input to stage 24 is the output 23 of stage 22, and the output 27 from stage 23 is a second input to stage 25 having an output 31 As the figure indicates, this process may be repeated any desired number of times, according to the accuracy with which it is desired to express signal 20: the final stage 26 is shown as energized from source 21. The output of the last stage 26 is shown at 33., and like the other stages, ithas a second input 32 derived from the output of a preceding stage.

In order to interpret the quantizer operation, indicators, 33, .34, 35, and 36 are energized with outputs 23, 27, 3t), and 31. These indicators may be any devices having bivalent response: a typical example is a signal lamp which is lit to indicate one output and dark to indicate the other. By observing the indications, the opera tor is able to determine the binary equivalent of the signal voltage.

If desired, outputs 23, 27, 3t and 31 may also be supplied to a bina-ryto-decima.l converter 37, which is arranged to operate a decimal indicator 4t? through a suitable connection 41.

It should be pointed out that Figure l is illustrative of a specific converter, in which the signal is supplied directly only to the first quantizer stage. Figure 1A is presented to indicate that quantizers are also known in which the input arrangement is reversed from that shown, the signal being supplied directly to all. stages and the standard being supplied directly to only the first stage. Other quantizers are discussed below which deviate from the block diagram in other specific respects: the general functioning of the quantizers remains the same throughout.

Reference should now be made to Figure 2, which shows four quant-izer stages, generally indicated at 59, 5'1, 52, and 53. Figure 2 is arranged for direct voltages, but can easily be arranged for alternating voltages, as is shown in connection with other modifications. Signal 29 is supplied between terminal 54 and ground, and is applied through conductor 55 and summing resisters 56, 57, 58, and 59, to summation points 61, 62, 6.3,and 64, respectively. *Source 21 is shown as supplying between terminals 65, 66, 67, and 70-, respectively and ground a standard voltage, a half-standard voltage, a quarter-standard voltage and an eighth-standard voltage. The standard voltage is equal in magnitude to half the maximum value of the signal anticipated. The voltages on terminals 65, 66, 67, and 70 are supplied to summation points 61, 62, 63, and 64 through summing resistors 71, 72, 73, and '74, all respectively. Each stage includes an amplifier and discriminator unit energized from the summation point and arranged to supply a relay operating output. The units are identical and only one has been shown in more than block diagram form. Unit 75 is shown to be connected to summation point 61 and to comprise an input resistor 76, a triode 77, and a source of anode potential 73 for the triode. It is connected to energize a relay 79 having a. winding 80 which actuates an armature 81 to displace a movable contact 82 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 83 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 84. Fixed contact 83 is grounded. Fixed contact 84 is connected to terminal 65 of source 21. Movable contact 82 is connected to summation points 62, 63, and64 byconductor 85 and resistors 86, 87, and

.88, respectively. Armature 81 is also extended to indicate the operation of the stage.

Summation point 62 is connected to an amplifier and discriminator unit 90 whose input resistor is shown at 91. The output of unit 90 is supplied to a relay 92 having a winding 93 which actuates an armature 94 to displace a movable contact 95 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 96 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 97. Fixed contact 96 is grounded. Fixed contact 97 is connected to terminal 66 of source 21. Movable contact 95 is connected to summation points 63 and 64 through conductor 98 and summing resistors 100 and 101, respectively. Armature 94 is extended to indicate the operation of the stage.

Summation point 63 is connected to an amplifier and discriminator unit 102 whose input resistor is shown at 103. The output of unit 102 is supplied to a relay 104 having a winding 105 which actuates an armature 106 to displace a movable contact 1107 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 110 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 111. Fixed contact 110 is grounded. Fixed contact 111 is connected to terminal 67 of source 21. Movable contact 107 is connected to summation point 64 through conductor 112 and summing resistor 113. Armature 106 is extended to indicate the operation of the stage.

Summation point 64 is connected to an amplifier and discriminator unit 114 whose input resistor is shown at 115. The output of unit 114 is supplied to a relay 116 having a winding 117 which aotuates an armature 120 to displace a movable contact 121 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 122 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 123. Fixed contact 122 is grounded. Fixed contact 123 is connected to terminal 70 of source 21. Movable contact 121 is connected to conductor 124. Armature 120 is extended to indicate the operation of the stage.

Resistors 56, 57, 58, 59, 71, 72, 73, 74, 86, 87, 88, 100, 101 and 113 are all of the same resistance. The signal and standard voltages, which do not reverse,are so polarized with respect to ground that they oppose one another at the respective summation points, as indicated by the polarities at terminals 54, 65, 66, 67, and 70.

Operation is as follows. For a zero signal none of relays 79, 92, 104, and 116 are operated. The voltages supplied to summation points 61, 62, 63, and 64 are 8 S 8 '57 -Z: and g respectively, where s is one-half the maximum value of x, the signal.

As x increases it exceeds the value The sense of the input to unit 114 now reverses, and relay 116 pulls in. If stage 53 is the last stage, no result follows in the quantizer from the operation of relay 116, although its indicating function is properly performed.

As x continues to increase it exceeds the value The sense of the input to unit 102 now reverses, and relay 116 pulls in, performing its indicating function and supplied a s/4 voltage from terminal 67 through resistor 113 to summation point 64. Since resistors 59, 74 and 113 are equal, the signal of whi is now opposed by the opposite and greater sum of standard voltages and relay 116 drops out, changing its indication accordingly.

As x continues to increase, it exceeds the value and The indication of the device remains the same after x passes a value no matter how much larger x becomes.

Table I Value of: Relay 79 ,Relay 92 Relay 104 Relay 116 g Operated.

s I Operated" 3s D 8 do 0 s Operated .do Do. 8

3s d0 Operated E d0 do Do.

s Operated do Do.

g; do OperatetL.

113 .d0 do Do.

...d0 Operated.

do do Do.

% do do Operated" do no do Do.

This table shows that as the signal voltage increases continuously the condition of the relays is a digital indication of the signal in the simple binary system.

It is obvious that if the value of x decreases instead of increasing, the inputs to the amplifiers reverse in sense at the appropriate values for x, and the operation of the apparatus remains proper.

The above described apparatus gives a four-place binary indication of the value of x. Increase in the number of places is accomplished simply by adding further quantizer stages. If the standard voltages are still related as increasing negative powers of two, that is, as

the indication remains a single binary number. It is sometimes convenient to modify the indications of the device so that they present the separate digits of a decimal number, each digit however, being expressed in binary form. This is accomplished as will now be described.

' Figure 3 is shown as continuous with Figure 2, conductors 55, 85, 98, 112, and 124 being those in the earlier figure extended. Four additional quantizer stages 125, 126, 127, and 130 are ShOWn in Figure 3 to have summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134 energized from conductor 55 through summing resistors 135, 136, 137, and 140, all respectively. Conductor 85 is connected to summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134 by summing resistors 141, 142, 143, and 144, respectively. Conductor 98 is connected to summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134 by summing resistors 145, 146, 147, and 150 respectively. Conductor 112 is connected to summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134 by summing resistors 151, 152, 1 53, and 154 respectively. Conductor 124 is connected to summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134 by summing resistors 155, 156, 157, and 160 respectively. Source 21 is shown as supplying further voltages at terminals 161, 162, 163, and 164, which are connected to summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134 by summing resistors 165, 166, 167, and 170, all respectively.

Quantizer stage 125 includes an amplifier and discriminator unit 171 whose input resistor is shown at 172. The output of unit 171 is supplied to a relay 173 comprising a winding 174 which actuates an armature 175 to displace a movable contact 176 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 177 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 180. Fixed contact 177 is grounded. Fixed contact 180 is connected to terminal 161 of source 21. Movable contact 176 is connected to summation points 132, 133, and 134 by conductor 181 and summing resistors 182, 183, and 184, respectively.

Quantizer stage 126 includes an amplifier and discriminator unit 185 whose input resistor is shown at 186. The output of unit 185 is supplied to a relay 187 comprising a winding 1% which actuates an armature 191 to displace a movable contact 192 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 1% and into engagement with a second fixed contact 194. Fixed contact 193 is grounded. Fixed contact 194 is connected to terminal 162 of source 21. Movable contact 192 is connected to summation points 133 and 134 by conductor 195 and summing resistors 196 and 197, respectively.

Quantizer stage 127 includes an amplifier and discriminator unit 200 whose input resistor is shown at 201. The output of unit 200 is supplied to a relay 202 comprising a winding 203 which actuates an armature 204 to displace a movable contact 205 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 206 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 20 7. Fixed contact 206 is grounded. Fixed contact 207 is connected to terminal 163 of source 21. Movable contact 205 is connected to summation point 134 by conductor 210 and summing resistor 211.

Quantizer stage 130 includes an amplifier and discriminator unit 212 whose input resistor is shown "at 213. The output of unit 212 is supplied to a relay 214 comprising a winding 215 which actuates an armature 216 to displace a movable contact 217 out of normal engagement with a first fixed contact 218 and into engagement with a second fixed contact 219. Fixed contact 220 is grounded. Fixed contact 221 is connected to terminal 164 of source 121. Movable contact 217 is connected to conductor 228.

It is thus apparent that Figure 3 is structurally a straightforward continuation of Figure 2. If the voltages at terminals 161, 162, 163, and164 were respectively 1/16, l/ 32, 1/64, and l/ 128 of standard, the two figures together would show an eight-place binary quantizer. However, the ratio between the voltage at terminal 161 of Figure 3 and that at terminal 70 of Figure 2 is not 132, but 4:5. The ratios for terminals 162, 163, and 164 are successively l/2, 1/4, and l-/8 that at terminal 161, so

*8 the increasing negative power of two relationship is again restored. In other words, the voltages at terminals 161, 162, 163 and 164 are respectively.

The operation of this modification dilfers from that of Figure 2. only in stage 125, as it is between this stage and stage 53 that the decimal division of the input is to occur. It is required that an increase of only two units of voltage-now 1/80 standard in magnitude-occur between operation of relay 173 and operation of relay 116. This limits the largest number which can be expressed in binary form by the indication of relays 173, 187, 222 and 214 to nine instead of to fifteen, nine being the largest digit in the decimal system. Relay 116 operates when the signal reaches l/ 8 standard and relay 173 operates when the signal reaches 1/ 10 standard. The difference, 2/ standard, is exactly equal to two increments of signal, which is the result desired.

Suppose the signal to have increased from zero to a magnitude of nine units. Then according to the principles explained in connection with Figure 2, relays 173 and 214 are operated and relays 77, 92, 104, 114, 187, and 202 are normal. If the signal increases to 10 units, relay 116 pulls in, supplying voltage from terminal 7 0 to summation points 131, 132, 133, and 134. The standard voltages at summation point 131 is now 1/8 standard plus 1/ 10 standard, or 18 units, which is larger than 10 units, so relay 173 drops out. The standard voltage on summation point 132 is now 1/ 8 standard plus 1/ 20 standard or 14 'units, so relay 187 does not pull in. The standard voltage at summation point 133 is now l/ 8 plus 1/40 standard, or 12 units, so relay 202 does not pull in. The standard voltage at summation point 134 is l/ 8 plus l/80' standard, or 11 units, and relay 214 drops out. A further increase of one unit in the signal causes relay 214 to pull in as described in connection with Figure 2.

It is thus apparent that the structure of Figures 2 and 3 together difiers from a simple eight-stage binary quantizer only in the choice of voltages for the second decimal unit, and in the estabilshment of 1/80 rather than 1/ 128 standard as the unit of voltage increment. These changes result in an output representing in simple binary form two digits of a decimal number. If a third decimal stage is desired, the structure is extended as is obvious to those skilled in the art in view of the above teaching: the standard voltages for the next four stages being 1/ 100, l/200, l/400, and 1/800 standard.

fT he foregoing quantizers are based on the binary number system: quantizers about to be described are based on the progressive binary number system. The difference is shown in Figure 15, where curve A represents a signal, to a quantizer stage, which varies from zero to some value. If the output from the quantizer stage may be represented by a discontinuous line B, the stage is simple binary: if the output may be represented by a broken line C, the stage is progressive binary.

In Figure 4 there is shown apparatus having a plurality of quantizer stages 220, 221, 222, and 223. In this embodiment of the invention the signal and standard voltages are shown as alternating rather than direct, and as derived from a transformer 224 having a primary winding 225 and a secondary winding 226 with end terminals 227 and 230 and an intermediate tap 231 so positioned that the voltage between tap 231 and terminal 227 is twice that between tap 231 and terminal 230. Tap 2.31 is connected to ground at 232, so that the voltages at terminals 227 and 230 are in degree phase relationship with respect to ground.

The block identified by reference character 233 represents any suitable analogue signal device, energized from terminal 227 and tap 231 of secondary winding 226 through conductor 234 and ground connections 235 

